Collecting: Status, Investment, or an Incurable Disease? - AUCBURG | AUCBURG
Collecting: Status, Investment, or an Incurable Disease?
Collecting is a complex and multifaceted topic that touches upon personal aspects of life and memories. It is not just the technical side of the antiques business, but rather a debate where opinions often diverge. What is it really: a confirmation of status, an uncontrollable passion, a kind of illness, or simply a hobby? Most likely, this phenomenon combines all these aspects.
What is Collecting: Passion, Status, or Investment?
Collecting is a complex and multifaceted topic that touches upon personal aspects of life and memories. It is not just the technical side of the antiques business, but rather a debate where opinions often diverge. What is it really: a confirmation of status, an uncontrollable passion, a kind of illness, or simply a hobby? Most likely, this phenomenon combines all these aspects.
Recently, it has become fashionable to collect items to emphasize one's status. When people have disposable income, they follow the hierarchy of needs and begin investing it in hobbies. Wealthy individuals often hire dealers who search the world for items to add to their collections. However, whether such a person is a collector in the truest sense of the word is a big question.
A true collector is defined not by the completeness and costliness of their collection, but by their state of mind. This is a person who is willing to give their last penny to acquire a coveted item. However, today the line between collecting and investing is blurring. Many, faced with a choice between a rare item for their collection and a profitable investment, will choose the latter, which detracts from the true essence of collecting.
The Four Pillars of a True Collector
True collecting is based on several key components. They distinguish a passionate collector from a mere investor or someone seeking status.
We can identify four main elements that form the foundation of this activity:
The hunter's instinct. This is the thrill, the process of preparation, tracking, and finally, the 'shot'—the moment of acquiring the coveted item. For a collector, just like for a hunter, this moment is the culmination for which the entire process is undertaken.
The research foundation. A true collector is an expert in their field. They study literature, catalogs, and the history of items, sometimes possessing deeper knowledge than museum staff. In the past, libraries served this purpose; today, the internet provides limitless opportunities for research.
Curation of the collection. This is an important, though often overlooked, aspect. There is a difference between storing and presenting a collection. For security reasons, many valuable collections are kept in bank vaults or safes, which prevents their proper display.
The opportunity to share. This point is not mandatory and depends on the person's character. Some collectors are self-sufficient introverts who enjoy their collection in solitude. Others, more outgoing, feel the need to show off and share their treasures with friends and like-minded people.
The Four Pillars of a True Collector
The Difference Between a Hunter and a Collector, and the Spirit of the Era
Although a collector and a hunter have much in common, there is a fundamental difference. A hunter almost always has the chance for a second shot if the first one fails. A collector often does not have this opportunity—a rare item can be gone forever. This is where the special charm and drama of collecting lie.
To understand the spirit of true collecting, one should look to the Soviet era. There is a 1962 documentary film called 'Collectors in the USSR. Serious Whimsies.' It perfectly captures the atmosphere of the 'stagnation' period, when there were true collectors driven by passion, not commercial gain.
The film shows various collecting trends of that time—from matchbox labels and small calendars to phaleristics. It is a very soulful movie that allows you to immerse yourself in the world of people for whom collecting was the meaning of life.
The Difference Between a Hunter and a Collector, and the Spirit of the Era
Peculiarities of German Collecting
Characteristic
Description
Collector's Profile
Typically, a middle-aged man (40-50 years old) with an above-average income, working in intellectual professions.
Financial Discipline
A German collector clearly plans their hobby budget (e.g., 300-500 euros per month) and never exceeds it.
Approach
Before starting to collect, a German will thoroughly study the subject, acquire all the necessary literature, and only then begin making purchases.
Curation
Great attention is paid to proper storage and presentation: first, expensive albums and storage systems are purchased, and then they are gradually filled.
German collectors have their own distinctive features, which are largely determined by their national character and standard of living. Having lived in Germany for 25 years, one can form a definite idea of their approach to this hobby.
First and foremost, the richness and luxury of German collections are striking. This is explained by the high standard of living in the country: people have disposable funds that they can invest in hobbies. However, not everyone here is engaged in collecting.
Such a pedantic and calculated approach is very different from the more emotional and sometimes chaotic style of collecting characteristic of collectors from the post-Soviet space. A German will never make an impulsive purchase, sacrificing something important for a rare specimen.
Peculiarities of German Collecting
Narrow Specialization vs. 'Omnivorous' Collecting
Another striking feature of German collectors is their narrow specialization. Unlike many of their Russian counterparts, who are interested in everything, Germans choose a very specific and limited field. This can be called the 'advanced school' of collecting.
For example, one collector might exclusively collect porcelain from the Fürstenberg manufactory, while another collects only the postage stamps of Schleswig-Holstein from a specific historical period. Such focus allows them to become true experts in their niche, capable of identifying a fake at a single glance.
The Russian approach, however, is often characterized as 'omnivorous.' A collector might simultaneously collect coins, pins, stamps, paintings, and much more. On the one hand, this is a drawback, as it's impossible to become a deep specialist in all areas at once. On the other hand, this approach significantly broadens one's horizons.
Narrow Specialization vs. 'Omnivorous' Collecting
The Tradition of Succession and Modernity
In Germany, the tradition of succession is very strong. If a collector has a family business, they will surely prepare a successor. The same applies to collections. A German collector will spend years preparing their children to pass on their collection and knowledge.
However, this tradition does not always stand the test of time. There is a known case of a porcelain collector from the city of Höchst. He owned a huge collection that occupied an entire apartment and spent 15 years preparing his son to be his successor, teaching him all the subtleties.
After his father's death, the son, a successful manager at a large company, decided to sell the entire collection. He explained that he had neither the time nor the desire to deal with it, and he wanted to use the money to buy a house in Spain. The collection was sold for a large sum, which shows how priorities are changing for the younger generation.
The Collector-'Maniac': A Story of True Passion
There is another type of collector, who can be called 'maniacs' in a good sense of the word. These are people consumed by a true, all-encompassing passion for collecting, which sometimes borders on an illness.
Once at a flea market, I met a man selling a huge collection of Goebel and Hummel porcelain figurines that had belonged to his late wife. She was a true collector: she secretly bought the figurines without her husband's knowledge and hid them in the attic.
After her death, her husband discovered that the entire attic was filled with boxes. It took him two weekends to bring down between 2,000 and 2,500 figurines. The man considered his wife 'crazy,' but it is precisely this behavior that is a manifestation of the genuine, boundless passion that drives a true collector.